
The winds of change have blown through Iowa and former pastor and outspoken Christian Republican candidate Mike Huckabee is now one step closer to the big boy chair in Washington.
Forgive me, this is where my first ammendment nerves begin to twitch. Let's take a quick stroll down memory lane while I scratch.
Two years ago, a "God-filled" quote by Purpose-Driven Life author Rev. Rick Warren appeared on millions of Starbucks coffee cups across America, leaving people on both sides of the religion-in-public debate talking.
The quote was simply one among many by prominent thinkers, artists, politicians and other cultural leaders designed by Starbucks to spark conversation while patrons sucked back their java. Warren's words weren't earth-shattering, but made headlines because they were overtly religious in nature.
To be fair, the cups carried a disclaimer that the notable quotes “do not necessarily reflect the views of Starbucks”. Personally, I had no problem with what they were trying to do. So long as a variety of opinions were expressed with no one dominating agenda, what was the damage? Overall, I thought it was a great idea.
It did, however, resurrect (excuse the pun) a question that's been brewing in my mind for years. At different times over the past decade or so, I’ve walked into Wal-Marts, Costcos, or Safeways to the beat of Christian muzak and “praise his holy name” anthems, wondering if such public places were appropriate venues for believing businesspeople to broadcast their private religious views.
I thought it was just me, but apparently others have noticed an increase in the presence of religion in public, too.
"Americans are more accepting of overt religiosity these days,” says sociologist David Halle, director of the LeRoy Neiman Center for the Study of American Society and Culture at the University of California-Los Angeles.
Okay. Now I have no problem with a rise in society's spirituality temperature. God knows we could use it. My concern has to do with when expressions of faith go public, and where the motivation behind those expressions comes from. Having been a pastor, I understand the mindset all too well: more often than not, believers put their views out there not as a form of self-expression or celebration but as a clear attempt to evangelize and convert the “unchurched”.
Now it is certainly every person’s right to hold and share their views (religious, political, or otherwise) with others. What is less certain is whether those beliefs should be delivered en masse through a store’s loudspeakers, where I am, in a sense, forced to listen to them whether I want to or not - especially when there is an undeniable agenda behind it, however benign that agenda may be.
I already know what some are thinking: we’re already inundated with propaganda in the form of suggestive advertising in grocery stores and product placement on television and in films. Fair enough. In deed, I am as disturbed by the corporate brainwashing of society as I am by anything religion has to offer. But the question remains: when, if ever, is it appropriate for people to share their private views publicly - especially when those private views impose a burden of required response on the listener?
Just to prove I’m not targeting religious believers per se, let me add that I wouldn’t be comfortable with a Marxist, an advocate of gay rights, or a member of the Parti Quebecois standing on an Ivory soap display in the middle of Costco and broadcasting his or her views, either. It’s just not the place. Picadilly Circus in London, sure. My local grocery store? Nuh uh.
Again, I have no problem with throwing a little faith and spirituality into the social mix. We need that. So what's at the root of my fear about faith in public? Simple: a little thing called history.
Every time religion slips over the tipping point into the mainstream, its marriage with politics influences social policy and laws that, despite our best intentions, eventually favour one worldview over others. In Iran, that means Islam. In American, melting pot or not, that means Christianity.
The quote was simply one among many by prominent thinkers, artists, politicians and other cultural leaders designed by Starbucks to spark conversation while patrons sucked back their java. Warren's words weren't earth-shattering, but made headlines because they were overtly religious in nature.
To be fair, the cups carried a disclaimer that the notable quotes “do not necessarily reflect the views of Starbucks”. Personally, I had no problem with what they were trying to do. So long as a variety of opinions were expressed with no one dominating agenda, what was the damage? Overall, I thought it was a great idea.
It did, however, resurrect (excuse the pun) a question that's been brewing in my mind for years. At different times over the past decade or so, I’ve walked into Wal-Marts, Costcos, or Safeways to the beat of Christian muzak and “praise his holy name” anthems, wondering if such public places were appropriate venues for believing businesspeople to broadcast their private religious views.
I thought it was just me, but apparently others have noticed an increase in the presence of religion in public, too.
"Americans are more accepting of overt religiosity these days,” says sociologist David Halle, director of the LeRoy Neiman Center for the Study of American Society and Culture at the University of California-Los Angeles.
Okay. Now I have no problem with a rise in society's spirituality temperature. God knows we could use it. My concern has to do with when expressions of faith go public, and where the motivation behind those expressions comes from. Having been a pastor, I understand the mindset all too well: more often than not, believers put their views out there not as a form of self-expression or celebration but as a clear attempt to evangelize and convert the “unchurched”.
Now it is certainly every person’s right to hold and share their views (religious, political, or otherwise) with others. What is less certain is whether those beliefs should be delivered en masse through a store’s loudspeakers, where I am, in a sense, forced to listen to them whether I want to or not - especially when there is an undeniable agenda behind it, however benign that agenda may be.
I already know what some are thinking: we’re already inundated with propaganda in the form of suggestive advertising in grocery stores and product placement on television and in films. Fair enough. In deed, I am as disturbed by the corporate brainwashing of society as I am by anything religion has to offer. But the question remains: when, if ever, is it appropriate for people to share their private views publicly - especially when those private views impose a burden of required response on the listener?
Just to prove I’m not targeting religious believers per se, let me add that I wouldn’t be comfortable with a Marxist, an advocate of gay rights, or a member of the Parti Quebecois standing on an Ivory soap display in the middle of Costco and broadcasting his or her views, either. It’s just not the place. Picadilly Circus in London, sure. My local grocery store? Nuh uh.
Again, I have no problem with throwing a little faith and spirituality into the social mix. We need that. So what's at the root of my fear about faith in public? Simple: a little thing called history.
Every time religion slips over the tipping point into the mainstream, its marriage with politics influences social policy and laws that, despite our best intentions, eventually favour one worldview over others. In Iran, that means Islam. In American, melting pot or not, that means Christianity.
I could go into a lengthy dissertation defending my feelings, and the more open-minded faithful could respond by saying that times have changed and that religion can have a positive influence on politics without going medieval. But I'll let the record of history (and of human nature) speak for itself. We can’t help it! The desire to influence others is part of any belief system’s package. Religion, by its very nature, breeds enthusiasm (not a bad thing) - enthusiasm that always engenders an urge to convert and change others - which, in the inevitable wrong hands, mutates into state-enforced morality and oppression (a very bad thing). However paranoid or bigotted or tired it sounds, that cycle has never varied. Politics plus religion for any significant length of time equals trouble. I challenge anyone to demonstrate otherwise.
That's why I'll always be a passionate supporter of the separation of church and state. Not because I am phobic about public faith discussions, or anti-religious, or the antichrist, but because it is too easy for a religion’s natural lobbying instincts to take root and take over. So thank God (if I may so bold) for constitutional amendments that keep religion at a reasonable arm’s length from the public sector.
Having said that, I think we should all lighten up and give Starbucks and Mike Huckabee a break. Warren's was one quote among sixty designed to spark the exchange of different points of view. Is that not democracy at it’s finest? And just because Huckabee is outspoken about where he comes from as a person of faith doesn't mean we're a presidential term or two away from a Christian state, does it?
That's why I'll always be a passionate supporter of the separation of church and state. Not because I am phobic about public faith discussions, or anti-religious, or the antichrist, but because it is too easy for a religion’s natural lobbying instincts to take root and take over. So thank God (if I may so bold) for constitutional amendments that keep religion at a reasonable arm’s length from the public sector.
Having said that, I think we should all lighten up and give Starbucks and Mike Huckabee a break. Warren's was one quote among sixty designed to spark the exchange of different points of view. Is that not democracy at it’s finest? And just because Huckabee is outspoken about where he comes from as a person of faith doesn't mean we're a presidential term or two away from a Christian state, does it?
Does it?
No comments:
Post a Comment