
Buying the best and the brightest
Alberta misses the obvious when planning for the future
Originally published in Edmonton's See Magazine
April 6, 2006
The provincial debt behind them, Albertan politicians are marching in lockstep towards the future. And the Tory cabinet, floating on a cloud of oil riches, have armed themselves with the political buzz-words du jour: "investment" and "innovation."
Despite the rhetoric, though, the most obvious target for investment and source of innovation–post-secondary education–has been all but ignored. This despite the fact that more Canadian jobs than ever–62 per cent and rising, according to Statistics Canada–require post-secondary education. The situation has reawakened a call to revisit the idea of free universal post-secondary education.
"Albertans definitely realize there is so much opportunity in this province to make a strong commitment to revamping and drastically improving Alberta’s entire advanced education system," Alberta Liberal Advanced Education critic Dave Taylor said last fall.
In the 2006 budget announcement, the Alberta government responded by committing $87 million to keep tuition for the 2006-07 year at 2004-05 levels.
"The government, post-secondary institutions, and businesses will continue working together to expand the province’s learning opportunities and find solutions to sill and labour shortages," said Advanced Education Minister Dave Hancock. "Post-secondary education remains a top government priority and our record-breaking budget of $2.2 billion backs that up."
But University of Alberta Student Union president, Graham Lettner, says the tuition freeze is not enough.
"What we didn’t see in the budget," says Lettner, "is a long-term strategy tied to long-term dollars. It’s nice for the short-term, but where will Alberta be in 10 to 20 years? It’s hard to get enthusiastic about a one-time infusion and be confident that the provincial government is improving accessibility and affordability of PSE to all Albertans in the long-term."
Students aren’t the only ones who are concerned. Lettner’s observations echoed those heard from James L. Turk, executive director of the Canadian Association of University Teachers. Turk, at the National Dialogue on Higher Education in Ottawa last November, pleaded with federal and provincial governments to dig deeper.
"Through the late ’60s, ’70s and ’80s," said Turk, "Canada built an enviable post-secondary education system that offered unprecedented access to universities and colleges."
Fiscal hack-job
The Mulroney government dramatically slashed federal transfer payments to provinces in 1986, including Alberta. The Mulroney trend was followed by radically deeper cuts in 1996 under Paul Martin fiscal guidance. Unsurprisingly, national tuition fees soared by 135% between 1991 and 2003.
"Any real solution requires a new commitment of the federal government to significant increases in provincial transfers for post-secondary education," said Turk. "Universities and colleges are precious institutions in our democratic society. Their gradual starvation, increasingly resulting in their transformation along industrial corporate lines, will be a disaster for Canada and for Canadians."
A disaster? Turk isn’t engaging in empty rhetoric. In fact, the United Nations 1976 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (to which Canada is a signatory nation), declared education a basic human right, and voted that not only elementary and secondary, but also "higher [post-secondary] education shall be made equally accessible to all, on the basis of capacity, by every appropriate means, and in particular by the progressive introduction of free education."
But that resolution is now 30 years old, and Canada’s commitment to it could be considered a relic. The Alberta government pledged to improve accessibility, with measures that include 60,000 new post-secondary spaces by 2010 and coverage of tuition increases in 2006-07. But that agenda does not address the fact that the portion of the total cost of education paid by Alberta students has increased from 15 per cent in 1990 to 35 per cent today–hardly a move towards "progressive free education."
The old saw is that free post-secondary education is neither sustainable nor fair. After all, students who graduate with a diploma or degree typically earn higher incomes–so why should government have to foot the bill? Statistics Canada shows that university graduates make, on average, $18,000 to $23,000 more per year than do their high school counterparts.
Overlooked, however is the fact degreed workers also pay between $7,000 and $8,000 more per year in federal and provincial taxes. Within five years, in other words, graduates will have paid the equivalent of the cost of their education indirectly in the form of taxes.
So the question of who benefits most from higher education is a dubious one: by double-charging students–tuition fees before graduation, higher taxes on every year of increased income after graduation–it appears that the government stands to gain as much, if not more, as the graduates themselves.
"The biggest obstacles to quality, universal post-secondary education," says Lettner, "are still accessibility and affordability. The province needs to focus on whatever it takes to demolish all barriers that keep post-secondary education expensive and scarce for too many Albertans."
Alberta misses the obvious when planning for the future
Originally published in Edmonton's See Magazine
April 6, 2006
The provincial debt behind them, Albertan politicians are marching in lockstep towards the future. And the Tory cabinet, floating on a cloud of oil riches, have armed themselves with the political buzz-words du jour: "investment" and "innovation."
Despite the rhetoric, though, the most obvious target for investment and source of innovation–post-secondary education–has been all but ignored. This despite the fact that more Canadian jobs than ever–62 per cent and rising, according to Statistics Canada–require post-secondary education. The situation has reawakened a call to revisit the idea of free universal post-secondary education.
"Albertans definitely realize there is so much opportunity in this province to make a strong commitment to revamping and drastically improving Alberta’s entire advanced education system," Alberta Liberal Advanced Education critic Dave Taylor said last fall.
In the 2006 budget announcement, the Alberta government responded by committing $87 million to keep tuition for the 2006-07 year at 2004-05 levels.
"The government, post-secondary institutions, and businesses will continue working together to expand the province’s learning opportunities and find solutions to sill and labour shortages," said Advanced Education Minister Dave Hancock. "Post-secondary education remains a top government priority and our record-breaking budget of $2.2 billion backs that up."
But University of Alberta Student Union president, Graham Lettner, says the tuition freeze is not enough.
"What we didn’t see in the budget," says Lettner, "is a long-term strategy tied to long-term dollars. It’s nice for the short-term, but where will Alberta be in 10 to 20 years? It’s hard to get enthusiastic about a one-time infusion and be confident that the provincial government is improving accessibility and affordability of PSE to all Albertans in the long-term."
Students aren’t the only ones who are concerned. Lettner’s observations echoed those heard from James L. Turk, executive director of the Canadian Association of University Teachers. Turk, at the National Dialogue on Higher Education in Ottawa last November, pleaded with federal and provincial governments to dig deeper.
"Through the late ’60s, ’70s and ’80s," said Turk, "Canada built an enviable post-secondary education system that offered unprecedented access to universities and colleges."
Fiscal hack-job
The Mulroney government dramatically slashed federal transfer payments to provinces in 1986, including Alberta. The Mulroney trend was followed by radically deeper cuts in 1996 under Paul Martin fiscal guidance. Unsurprisingly, national tuition fees soared by 135% between 1991 and 2003.
"Any real solution requires a new commitment of the federal government to significant increases in provincial transfers for post-secondary education," said Turk. "Universities and colleges are precious institutions in our democratic society. Their gradual starvation, increasingly resulting in their transformation along industrial corporate lines, will be a disaster for Canada and for Canadians."
A disaster? Turk isn’t engaging in empty rhetoric. In fact, the United Nations 1976 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (to which Canada is a signatory nation), declared education a basic human right, and voted that not only elementary and secondary, but also "higher [post-secondary] education shall be made equally accessible to all, on the basis of capacity, by every appropriate means, and in particular by the progressive introduction of free education."
But that resolution is now 30 years old, and Canada’s commitment to it could be considered a relic. The Alberta government pledged to improve accessibility, with measures that include 60,000 new post-secondary spaces by 2010 and coverage of tuition increases in 2006-07. But that agenda does not address the fact that the portion of the total cost of education paid by Alberta students has increased from 15 per cent in 1990 to 35 per cent today–hardly a move towards "progressive free education."
The old saw is that free post-secondary education is neither sustainable nor fair. After all, students who graduate with a diploma or degree typically earn higher incomes–so why should government have to foot the bill? Statistics Canada shows that university graduates make, on average, $18,000 to $23,000 more per year than do their high school counterparts.
Overlooked, however is the fact degreed workers also pay between $7,000 and $8,000 more per year in federal and provincial taxes. Within five years, in other words, graduates will have paid the equivalent of the cost of their education indirectly in the form of taxes.
So the question of who benefits most from higher education is a dubious one: by double-charging students–tuition fees before graduation, higher taxes on every year of increased income after graduation–it appears that the government stands to gain as much, if not more, as the graduates themselves.
"The biggest obstacles to quality, universal post-secondary education," says Lettner, "are still accessibility and affordability. The province needs to focus on whatever it takes to demolish all barriers that keep post-secondary education expensive and scarce for too many Albertans."
No comments:
Post a Comment