Thursday, January 03, 2008

Celebrities - Are Their Lives Our Business?


Ever read one of those headlines that is so obvious to the general public you're at a loss as to why it's being published as "breaking news"?

I went online earlier today and read "Celebrity Rumor Denials Often Mask Truth" on the Yahoo news homepage. I couldn't resist, I had to click. It was like reading, "Donald Trump Reported to Be Hard-Ass" or "Recent Studies Show That Smoking Isn't Good For You."

I was quickly taken to an article by Jake Coyle entitled "Deny, Deny, Deny: Celebs Straddle the Truth". His premise was thought-provoking: he was suggesting that famous people tend to deny or cover up their personal problems when confronted by the media. Geez, y'think?

Mr. Coyle, let me ask you a question: what would you do if you walked out of your bedroom and there was a camera crew waiting there to ask if you'd farted at any point during the previous evening? Or imagine standing like a vertical sardine on the morning LRT at rush hour and being asked by a complete stranger if you and your wife had fought any time in the last forty-eight hours, and oh by the way, do you use Viagra?

Settle down, Jake, I'm sure your article was as tongue-in-cheek as mine here. We all know Brad and Jennifer were full of crap when they said all was well at the beginning of the year, or that they're hardly trendsetters when it comes to fudging the facts in public.

But can you blame them? You see, as far as I'm concerned the real question is, who the hell are we to be asking questions about their personal life in the first place?

Right about now I'm waiting for someone to throw me the well-used "public domain" argument that says when individuals opt for careers as, say, actors or musicians, they accept the burden of celebrity and became fair game. We, the public, have the right not only to know (and judge) every sordid detail of their private lives if we so wish, but to go to whatever lengths are necessary to retrieve said knowledge through our proxy houndog, the media.

But says who? Someone has a passion to act or play a guitar and, because our culture values those roles a certain way, it's assumed that, should they be lucky enough to become successful, not only do I but also my next-door neighbour and the guy I work become privy to knowing what cereal they eat and who they've slept with? Who decided that?

In "Does Celebrity Destroy Privacy", former First Amendment lawyer Julie Hilden asks, "Often, it is the intensely private aspects of a celebrity's life - involving drugs, sex or sexual orientation, marital discord, issues with children or other family members, or similar topics - that the public and the media deem newsworthy. (Illegality only ratchets up the stakes, and increases interest in the story.) But is the public entitled to know such private details about a celebrity, just because that person is a public figure?"

No, Hilden argues. Referring to the "public domain" (or in her words, the "waiver") argument as "a sort of Faustian bargain: lifelong fame in exchange for the lifelong loss of privacy", she suggests that "it seems somewhat unfair to say that because a person's gift lies in acting, basketball, or singing, rather than, for example, engineering, architecture, or computer science, that he or she has somehow 'chosen' to give up all of his or her privacy.

"My guess is that, for most celebrities, loss of privacy hurts anew every time."

Because - newsflash - they're people just like us. Despite their sometimes bulletproof public facade (produced in no small part by our strangely hypocritical worship-'em/crucify-'em relationship with celebrity), they have feelings and rights to privacy. For this reason, while agreeing that public figures, by definition, expose themselves to a unique kind of public scrutiny, Hilden refuses to fault celebrities for withholding or even fudging key facts about their private lives."

Consider [supermodel Naomi] Campbell's denials of her drug use. The truth is that, when asked about possible drug use by reporters, Campbell had little choice but to lie. The truth about Campbell's drug use - which she owed to a judge, but not necessarily to an interviewer - might have put her in prison. And it certainly would have forced her to expose to the public what goes on in her home and with her body, areas she ought to be able to protect."

The fact is, it's none of our business and they are under no obligation to tell us a damn thing. "When private facts are at issue," Hilden concludes, "a celebrity need not always be frank and truthful - any more than they need appear at a photo shoot nude simply because the photographer and the public would prefer it.

Envy, resentment, or plain-old curiosity may drive us to think we have the right to know; but if ever there was a time to dust off the Golden Rule, shouldn't it be when we're trying to decide if it's necessary (never mind decent or fair) to peruse someone's private phonebook and post the results online? This isn't rocket science: would you want all the names between A and Z in your daytimer to grace tomorrow morning's headlines? How about a picture of you staggering off the throne at 6 am, or picking your nose on your coffee break? C'mon, you know the answer.

Besides, at least they're doing something with their lives. Which is apparently more than can be said for those who have nothing better to do than eat from the garbage cans in Hollywood's back alleys.

------------------

Further Reading:

Celebrity, Privacy, and American Culture (American Bar Association)
Celebrity Privacy Claims Trump Public Justice, by Paul K. McMasters (American Press Institute)
Property, Privacy, and Paparazzi, by Tad Crawford (Allworth Press.com)
More Laws Are Needed to Protect Privacy, by Adam Pilar

No comments: