
The last four weeks have been good to me at the old Cineplex. Well, let me clarify: they've been good in the sense that I've been able to get to a lot of movies. The movies themselves, well that's another story.
Summer is always a time of big promises and guaranteed letdowns, interspersed with the occasional gem. This year is no exception: Recently, I've alternately endured/enjoyed The Island, Batman Begins, Land of the Dead, War of the Worlds, The Fantastic Four, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, Mr. & Mrs Smith, and Wedding Crashers.
The kid in me wants to silently thank the fates that I was able to break from my arduous schedule and get to a theatre at all. The human being in me feels compelled to either warn or encourage my fellow man regarding this year's pick of mold and gold. Here goes.
The Island: A good cast goes a long way and the combination of Ewan McGregor and Scarlett Johansson works well here. (Frankly, Johansson alone, in her 70s-style white jumper, was worth the price of admission, the movie's other merits and faults be damned.) In this Brave New World meets The Sixth Day pseudo-epic, director Michael Bay (Bad Boys II, Armageddon) manages to break free from his standard decibel-bending, crash-and-burn pyrotechnics long enough to marinate a satisfying story.
In a remote area somewhere in the world, a community of lucky survivors have been plucked from the aftermath of an apparent holocaust (here called "contamination") and placed in an indoor utopia, a massive facility that is one part World Gym, two parts Tokyo shopping mall. Everything from blood sugar to urine salinity to mood is measured and recorded to ensure optimum health of all the inmates (uh, I mean, residents). The audience suspects something isn't right, but Bay manages to keep the secret well enough that when the curtain gets pulled, the revelation is genuinely surprising.
The film's many themes - corporate power, cloning, and racism to name a few - are explored well. Unfortunately, half way through, Bay can't resist his penchant for dumb action and the film gets temporarily lost in some fantastically implausible (though admittedly, fun) bits. Nonetheless, I found The Island an enjoyable film overall. I just wish it could have avoided the easy "action" sell and stuck to the high drama that made the first half so fun to follow.
Batman Begins: Probably my favourite film of the summer pick. Great build-up, satisfying pay-offs, plausible dialogue, well-constructed back story, and great performances, especially by Christian Bale (the best Batman so far) and Michael Caine, who's paternal watchcare as Alfred is the story's heart. Bruce Wayne's spiritual and physical preparation for Batdom is great stuff, as is the gruelling contruction of the Bat Cave and the assembly of his requisite gear. This is exactly the kind of hard work a real human being would have to do in order to become a superhero.
Cillian Murphy's Dr. Crane/Scarecrow is perfect, neither over the top nor two-dimensional. Again, a bad guy who's a real person. Some people I talked to didn't like Liam Neeson but I loved him. Either way, it was fascinating to see the Dark Knight's worlds - both Gotham and the complicated world within him - explored fully for the first time since Tim Burton's original. By the way, I'm not one of those people who thinks the first Batman was a classic. It was good, but this is better.
Land of the Dead: You've got to go a movie like this expecting little. I did and so I enjoyed it for what it was. I'm a sucker for zombie movies anyway, and while I appreciate it when they're done well (Romero's original Dawn of the Dead or 2002's 28 Days Later), I'll take whatever I can get if I'm in the right mood. Romero, however, always goes beyond pure bloodletting to comment on society in his Dead films: we are all living half-asleep, feeding off each other for our personal gain, not really sure where we're going half the time and oblivious to the havoc we wreak. It's not a particularly affirmative message, but it's hard to argue against.
In Dawn of the Dead, he attacked society's mindless consumerism (a message that was mostly lost in the more mainstream 2004 remake). In Land, he identifies with the walking dead. Here they represent society's outcasts: the homeless, poor people, immigrants, people trying to make fresh starts. We are asked to sympathize with them against the living rich who exploit them. Overall, it works, despite the dialogue cliches and hackneyed scareshots that abound.
War of the Worlds: Say what you want about him, but somewhere between Cocktail and this summer, Tom Cruise learned how to act. I watched Top Gun the other day and, by contrast, his more recent turns (Minority Report, The Last Samurai, and Worlds) seem downright Shakespearian. His portrayal of working man/absentee father Ray Ferrier is just what it's supposed to be. Here Cruise channels two of his previous roles: Cocktail's high-octane Brian Flanagan and Magnolia's ultra-protected Frank T. J. Mackey. As in 2002's Signs (another film about parents trying to keep their shit together during an alien invasion), the invasion itself is not really what the story is about. It's the backdrop to the real theme of human survival in hard times, even extraordinarily hard times. The action starts quickly and Spielberg portrays the genocide with the same gritty and disturbing realism as he did in Saving Private Ryan. The ending is a bit of a letdown - the explanation of the aliens' defeat is vague and unsatisfying -, but the theme of how human beings survive (the golden cord that runs through all of Spielberg's films) is carried and resolved well.
The Fantastic Four: What a supreme letdown. The fantastic bore. After Spiderman and X-Men (a total of four winners so far), I was pumped and ready for this one. The trailers left me uncertain, but not even Daredevil or Hulk could shake my optimism that Marvel would deliver on the goods here. Alas, Fantastic Four is crap and not even very good crap at that. It definitely qualifies for my 20 All-Time Cheesiest Films list, but will never make my So-Bad-It's-Good list. The premise is ridiculous. I mean, I was willing to suspend my belief regarding the impact of radioactive material on human physiology (it would give most of us real people cancer, or at least a bad case of the runs) for Spiderman, the X-Men, and even the Hulk, because the characters were empathetic and the stories were well-developed. F4 is pure drivel. The dialogue is terrible, the acting entirely two-dimensional, the plot uninteresting, and get this: these crime-fighting superheroes don't actually fight any crime! Nothing happens in this movie. Nothing but a cheesy romance that no one buys (or cares about) and a villain that never builds enough momentum to be truly menacing (or interesting). The only problems they have to solve, the only messes they have to clean up are the ones they make in the first place. They are pure celebrities riding on a wave of popularity based on having achieved absolutely nothing that benefits society in any way. Dear God, may the bigwigs at 20th Century Fox pursue all other options before considering a sequel to this celluloid turd. Amen.
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory: I adore Roald Dahl's writing, Tim Burton's directing, Johnny Depp's acting, and Danny Elfman's scores. How could a film that combines all four go wrong? And yet it does. Let me start by saying that I think comparisons to 1971's Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory are unfair: although I find it odd that that movie was more about Charlie and this one is more about Wonka. But whatever. The two films stand alone and aim at different things, so should be judged separately. I loved Gene Wilder's Wonka because he was ultimately a warm and caring guy; but I was always bugged by that because it didn't match Dahl's 100% wierd chocolatier. The trailers led me to believe that Burton and Depp would capitalize on the wierdness factor and bring us Wonka as Dahl intended. But for the second time in his career, Depp actually disappointed me.
Wonka is an eccentric and Depp does eccentric well (think Capt. Jack Sparrow), but he goes too far and into areas that neither make sense nor are necessary. And who cares why Wonka is so messed up? Who cares about his overbearing dentist father, that Dahl never discussed in the first place? This subplot backstory is worse than unnecessary, it hurts the central plot. I liked that Wonka was a mystery. To have him explained kills it. I thought this was about Charlie anyway, who by the way is the best part of the film. Freddie Highmore plays the central character perfectly, and Burton is wise to spend as much time as he does with the Bucket family. The film is definitely fun to look at - I love Burton's bizarro sets and twisted subliminal montages - but that's the best I can say for it. That and the Bucket family. Depp, sad to say, detracts more than he adds.
(Postscript: Just returned from a second viewing with my kids. Better the second time, especially watching them enjoy it. Even enjoyed Depp.)
Mr. & Mrs Smith: I must admit, I was skeptical about this one. I don't mind Pitt and Jolie, but there not my favourites. Having previously produced the two Bourne Identity movies filmed to date, Doug Liman doesn't shy away from action in his directorial debut. Yet as in War of the Worlds, the action is only backdrop for the real story, which is about how marriages fall apart and, ultimately, the choices that can keep them together. Yes, Mr. & Mrs Smith is a sexy and dangerous film with great action sequences (really, how could it not be, with Pitt and Jolie on board); but its When Harry Met Sally-esque bookends and counseling sessions between Pitt and master therapist Vince Vaughn, make it clear that this is a film about relationships.
Unlike Prizzi's Honour or The War of the Roses, two films that share a kindred spirit but end sadly, Mr. & Mrs Smith ends on an up-note without settling for quick and easy resolutions. Maybe I liked the movie because I'm in the middle of a divorce myself. Either way, it's refreshing to see a film that encourages fidelity and commitment while still honouring the fact that relationships are hard work, and wraps it all up in some good kick-ass action!
Wedding Crashers: A complete surprise that ended up being one of my favourite films of the year. I went into this one against my will, truth be told. I mean, I love Vaughn and Wilson, but this one just looked D.U.M.B., a renter at best. Whodda thunk? Wedding Crashers is smart, funny as hell, and takes a fresh and honest look at relationships. Sure it's riddled with the expected cliches, implausibilities, and leaps of logic, but it's got a heart and brains, not to mention some of the funniest lines of all time.
Wilson and Vaughn are best friends but are very different in their approaches to relationships. Both are looking for love but only Wilson can admit it, at least in the beginning. As predicted, their long-time hobby is crashing weddings to meet chicks, and they're good at it. In the process, though, Wilson has become dissatisfied with the game and begins looking for a real relationship. The laughs and lessons that follow are classic. I'm sure I liked this one, at least in part, for the same reason I liked Mr. & Mrs Smith: it's about relationships and what makes good ones last. I'll pay good money for that over the Fantastic Snore any day, even if Jessica Alba does look good in blue.
