
Stanley Ipkiss. Fletcher Reede. Ace Ventura. The Cable Guy. The Grinch. Bruce "Almighty" Nolan. What do they have it common? That's right. Jim Carrey.
The list goes on: Lloyd Christmas (Dumb and Dumber), Officer Charlie Baileygates/Hank Evans (Me, Myself, & Irene), The Riddler (Batman Forever), Count Olaf (A Series of Unfortunate Events). Over the past decade, Carrey has played the gamut of good guys and bad guys, smart guys and stupid guys, down-to-earth guys and heaven-sent guys. But underneath all the characters that Canada's most famous neurotic has brought to the screen, he's really only ever played one: the guy who just doesn't seem able to grow up.
Even in his more serious films - The Truman Show, Man on the Moon, The Majestic, Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind - he is still the maladjusted boy-man who isn't sure who he is or where he fits. He is today's "typical guy". And judging by box office receipts it seems a lot of people are watching his films, hoping to find the answer to the question, Why does it take men so long to grow up?
When I posed that question last November (in "To All Men Just Starting to 'Get It'"), one woman responded:
"Paul, you say that men don't get it as soon as women?? But is that true? Maybe we don't get it and grow up too fast. Maybe we don't appreciate the fact that it takes men longer and we have to learn how to support each other on the journey . . ."
Wow, I thought to myself, a woman willing to meet a man half way. Maybe there's hope. After several hours spent trying to confirm that a woman had actually written this, I went to bed and had my first good sleep in weeks.
Next morning, however, I awoke and realized that, comforting though it was, her comment hadn't really answered my original question: Why does it take men so long to grow up?
Here's my theory. It ain't perfect, but it's a start:
I'd like to claim total originality for it, but I can't. In The Hero With A Thousand Faces, Joseph Campbell suggests that Western society, having de-ritualized and cleansed itself from key rites of passage common in virtually every other culture, is to blame for the current epidemic of boy-men: guys who at age forty haven't moved beyond the emotional maturity and responsibility of sixteen year-olds.
Think about it, it wasn't always like it is today. For thousands of years, communities and villages (including many today) were structured to support boys and girls as they became men and women. Every civilization expressed their support differently, of course, through different cultural forms of initiation and passage, but the core elements remained the same.
For a typical boy, it may have looked something like this:
1. He would wake up before the sun rose and go to work on the family farm or shop, where he'd been trained and working since he was seven years old. Work was non-negotiable: he was expected to carry his share of the load. (Man builder #1: Hard work)
2. When dad was away at work or at war, he was the man of the house. The responsibility was his to help mom maintain and protect the home. (Man builder #2: Responsibility at home)
3. When he was twelve, a special ritual took place that helped him make the mental leap: I am becoming a man now. (Man builder #3: Ritual & social accountability to be a man)
4. As soon as possible, he was trained for battle, since war was commonplace. For better or worse, both war and its complex preparations forced boys to deal with many of life's harsh realities and responsibilities. (Man builder #4: War & the discipline of preparation for war)
5. He was trained to look up to the "greyhairs" of his tribe or clan. Being older meant being wiser, and wisdom garnered respect. Maturity into manhood was a most desirable goal. (Man builder #5: Cultural attitude that it's cool to grow up)
6. Shorter lifespans, family duties, and the need to protect the community meant that the road to manhood had to be travelled as quickly as possible. (Man builder #6: Hard life, urgent priorities)
That was then. This is what we have today:
1. 80% of us now live in cities, where there are no family farms and few family trades in which to work, learn, and mature. Parents are running around so fast that many of them don't take the time to train (or even ask) their kids to take part in household chores. (Man killer #1: Light work, few expectations)
2. Whether or not dad is home, many boys have already been sent a clear message that little will be expected of them around the house, so it rarely even occurs to them that they're the "man of the house". (Man killer #2: No responsibility in the home)
3. As a civilization still rooted largely in Puritan values, we North Americans consciously - and after that, unconsciously - rid ourselves of rituals early on. The original idea was that rites and sacramental symbols were "idolatrous." After that, more enlightened Americans simply dismissed these as unnecessary clutter in the utilitarian march toward a hard-working and prosperous society.
The psychological ripple of this today is that, while adolescent girls are reminded every month that they are becoming women through the "ritual" of menstruation, boys have nothing. Without some external rite of passage, they lack a key instructional tool that, in the past, helped boys make the psychological transition to manhood.
There is another "ritual" that women engage in constantly: the ritual of talking. Women have been trained, since time immemorial, to talk honestly and freely about absolutely everything, most importantly their feelings and what it means to be a woman. It was built into the culture as women waited for men to return form the hunt, or were segregated from the tribe during menstruation. We men have not received similar modelling or training from our faithers, so we don't talk, and thus we grow up awkwardly and in often painful solitude. (Man killer #3: No ritual, no social accountability to become a man)
4. Most North Americans have only experienced war on film and, of course, I think that's a good thing. Except that, without something else to take war's place, men lack the "playground" to develop key elements of their manhood. In general, I'm a pacifist, so it sounds strange to hear myself saying that; but experience has told me that we men need healthy channels to express our "dangerous" side and build qualities like courage and perseverance through adventure, even if only mock adventure. In Asian cultures, martial arts training still helps foster the mental, physical, and emotional discipline necessary for a complete transition to manhood. In our culture, sports occupy a similar role. However, the self-discipline and group-responsibility aspects of sports are increasingly threatened by the egocentric lure of celebrity and lucrative corporate ad contracts. (Man killer #4: Few structured programs to instill self-discipline)
5. And what about the "gray hairs", the older men we once respected and whose leadership we needed? Well, how do we view seniors today? In short, as totally uncool and having nothing to offer. They're not plugged into an MP3 player and don't know who Puff Daddy is, so how could they have anything to say to us? Besides that, many older men have abdicated their roles as models and leaders, so many of us have no men to look up to. (This is a problem that will, of course, only grow worse with each new generation of men that shirks its responsibility.)
So what do we do with our golden oldies? Stick them in nursing homes where we don't have to look at them. The heritage of the 60s generation, driven home by the relentless propaganda of modern boomer-based advertising, is the mantra that growing up isn't cool. Today, it's all about staying young and wacky, for as long as possible. As a society, we stopped listening to our "greyhairs" about forty years ago. (I don't consider myself a traditionalist or even a conservative, but there's no doubt in my mind that this is a change for the worst.) The result is unequivocal: our collective cultural consciousness has been branded with the idea that growing up can and should be delayed as long as possible (Man killer #5: Cultural attitude that it's not cool to grow up)
6. People live longer today, and easier. And parents are more determined (and able) than ever to give their children the "good life." Which means there's even less of a rush and a push to grow up. It's entirely possible for boys to live their entire adolescence in front of a T.V., with an X-Box on one side and a Coke on the other, never having to confront the challenges or endure the experiences that could turn them into men. Thirty years later, the picture hasn't changed, except that the Coke has become a Budweiser. (Man killer #6: Easy life that requires little of boys)
I remember reading something a couple of years ago indicating that cults, gangs, and terrorist organizations typically draw a certain kind of person: single men, ages 18 to 30. Why? Because men are goal-driven. We need something to do! Whatever the changes in our society, our genes still carry that ancient impulse to conquer, to achieve, to make something of ourselves, to live a significant life. And when we can't do that, we go crazy - in some cases, literally!
Historically, that energy was channelled in ways that contributed to society, and also helped boys become men. Boys simply had to become men, it was key to their survival and the survival of the tribe. Today we don't have to become men. Well, let's face it, yeah we do; but because it doesn't appear to us to be absolutely necessary, and because we haven't really been equipped to become the men that women and the world need us to be, we postpone it. Indefinitely.
Meanwhile, because the aspiring man in us remains, we channel all that male energy in the most unproductive of ways - at the game console, at the nightclub, in street fights - instead of where it matters most: in our hearts, character, behaviour and relationships. Thus we drive our partners crazy and are branded "typical males".
It used to bug me when girls in my grade 10 class dated 20 year-old guys. What was wrong with us, I pondered. We'd be happy to oblige! Oh how little we understood that a guy in his twenties was only starting to reach the maturity level of most 15 year-old girls. At 16, we boys didn't have a chance. Makes sense now: just because you're male doesn't mean you're a man.
So I'm working on it. Like a lot of guys, I've paid a price for being a boy well past boyhood - in my marriage, in my career moves, in who I am fundamentally. So I appreciate it when women like the one above take the time to understand men: that we're not all jerks out to ruin their lives, despite all appearances. Many of us are really doing our best with what we've got. But we can improve, we can become the men you need and deserve.
Just give us a little time. Okay, a little more time.
Additional credit for this theory must be given to my friend Colleen, and that greatest of all teachers, Life.
Read "Short Pants" at Bravus for another view.
2 comments:
Paul, as a teenage girl I have often wondered at this great mystery of guys just not growing up. Though I will admit to being interested in older guys I really would rather date someone my own age and in the same stage of life (2nd year college ish). I'm still hoping that more guys get it, and that I can understand it. This posting helped. thanks
Paul remember, just by acknowledging the journey before you, You are already well on your way. (and YOU are not as far away as you may think). Thanks for part credit.
Post a Comment