Wednesday, May 25, 2005

No Conspiracy Required: Vaccine Development & the Squeezing of the Third World



"Drug companies are wary of admitting publicly what everyone knows to be true: that the size of a market affects how much they invest in it."

-- James Surowiecki in The New Yorker, December 20 & 27, 2004

I think I was in high school when I started hearing those delicious conspiracy theories about how the powerful are always looking for ways to marginalize the powerless.

It was a compelling argument: after all, history (not to mention the basketball court out back) was replete with examples. And the books we were given to read - Lord of the Flies, Brave New World, 1984, Animal Farm, all potent Social Darwinistic stuff - only deepened my proletariat suspicions. To a seventeen year-old coming into his own, it was downright irresistible, and I was smugly grateful to have found the right bandwagon so early in life.

By my late-twenties, I had other things on my mind and dismissed my earlier views as a sophomoric oversimplification. Nothing was as black and white, as cloak and dagger as that. Power relationships, I'd learned, were complex. After a few years of marriage, three kids, and a decade in the workforce, you understand that and get used to it. There were no sinister plans to relegate society's undesirables to some prison island a la "Escape from New York", no black-hooded men in some dark room plotting the triumph of the "elite", whoever they were. That was the stuff of Hollywood, of conspiracy theories.

More recently, however, I've discovered that you don't need a conspiracy to marginalize or even remove a certain class of people from "good society". It can happen as the unconscious, unintended result of the way developed nations direct their economies and manage their priorities.

Case in point: vaccine development for the disease-ravaged, and mostly poor and illiterate Third World.

In his Christmas 2004 editorial on global vaccine reasearch, James Surowiecki suggests that Western market forces have, for decades, prevented the pharmaceutical industry from providing any meaningful solutions to Africa's disease problem, resulting in the death of thousands of Africans every year.

"Usually," writes Surowiecki, "a company that invents something useful doesn't have much trouble selling it. But vaccines - especially for diseases in the developing world - are notorious exceptions to this rule. To begin with, Third World countries have unimaginably tiny amounts to spend on public health. (The poorer African countries spend eighteen dollars per person a year on health. We spend five thousand dollars.)

"This, of course, virtually guarantees that disease will continue to be a part of daily life on that continent for years to come."

Drug companies," he continues, "have put very little money into vaccine research. They'd much rather invest in an anti-arthritis drug that well-insured Americans will take every day than a vaccine that may command a fair price. (Just a few years ago, a promising malaria-vaccine candidate that had been tested in Papua, New Guinea was abandoned for lack of funding.) Meanwhile, diseases like malaria and tuberculosis have continued to ravage the Third World. Hundred of millions of people are newly affected every year."

Surowiecki does offer a couple of proactive solutions that could level the playing field and give meaningful vaccine development a chance. But it would take years and a near-miraculous change of heart (never mind policy) to move broadly and quickly enough to spare the thousands that die daily.

No, conspiracy or not, I cannot shake the the root of my high school suspicions. In Surowiecki's own words, "the burden of disease has helped keep sub-Saharan Africa poor" and the population in check.

The West's corporate obsession with "staying competitive", and the growing influence of big business on government is resulting, if only indirectly, in a culling of the Third World population tatamount to a "velvet genocide". It's happening, we all know it's happening, but since no one can be nailed for consciously orchestrating a kind of Third World "Final Solution", governments and business can shake their heads sympathetically while making no significant policy changes that would solve the problem.

In other words, some of life's most frightening realities and events require no plots or melodrama, no Devils or Emperor Palpatines, to nonetheless tear at the fabric of human happiness and ruin lives. More often, it seems that all we need to do is nothing, to pursue our own happiness and simply forget that the person next to us, or across the sea from us, is only trying to do the same thing.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

It's pretty simple, actually: this is the inevitable result of policies that allow the market to set morality. It should be the other way around, but all the 'reforms' of the past two decades in most Western countries have been in the direction of deregulation. An approach where governments mandate a specific proportion of R & D for vaccine research seems restrictive these days, but it's how problems like this will get fixed. And most people actually think this is a good idea and the right way to run the world - except a few neocon ideologues who happen to be driving the policy settings...

Anonymous said...

Conspiracy theory? Maybe...maybe not. I'm sure you've heard of the New World Order. Well..somewhere in all the documents I've read there is a push to eliminate 1 billion people. Is it true? I hope not!! (probably not) One can hope that someone takes the task on to help these people from the represive governments that hold the citizens back from the basics of life while the leaders live the life of luxury. But Western countries and European countries continue to give them money. Why? Give them the medicine they need, the proper food for nutrution, basic services like water and sewer instead of just money.