Sunday, December 12, 2004

LOTR's Aragorn - Is He "What Women Want"?



Legolas (Orlando Bloom) and Aragorn (Viggo Mortensen) accept the 'man' challenge and save the day in "The Return of the King" (New Line Cinema, 2003)


Tuesday's the big day and as a matter of fact, yes, I will be buying the extended DVD of "The Return of the King". Thanks for asking!

Aaah, I remember those glorious days between November 2001 and the same month in 2003 when the whole world seemed to sit on the edge of its seat, waiting for the next installment in the trilogy. I don't think I've felt that level of excitement since the first three (and to this day, still the best - sorry, George) Star Wars movies hit the screen and basically defined my childhood.

Love 'em or hate 'em, few can deny the LOTR films are big fun, chock full o' high adventure, archetypes aplenty, and life lessons to chew on for hours.

Somehow Peter Jackson managed to do what we all thought was impossible, suceeding precisely where George Lucas has gone astray: weave a great story and brilliant effects into a thoroughly (and consistently) convincing human drama, in which audiences could identify or empathize with virtually everyone on the screen.

But enough of that. This is no movie review. I was just reading an article by Bernard Chapin at mennewsdaily.com, entitled "Defending the Ring and Tolkien", in which he defends "Lord of the Rings" against charges of sexism from Andrea Lewis.

Now this is not the first time this debate has come up, and I'm not going go into it here. (Hit the links above if you're interested.) But the articles did remind me of an experience I've had more than a few times when talking with women who have seen the LOTR movies.

Despite their politics and specific impressions of the films, I always - I repeat, always - get unanimous and enthusiastic consensus on one point: Aragorn is to die for!

Of course, Legolas is nothing to sneeze at either - he definitely comes in a close second. But there's just something about that Ranger from the north.

Being a man, and always wanting to know how I can improve on that, I'm naturally curious as to why it is that Aragorn that draws such an undissuadable female fan base.

It doesn't take long to come up with a short list: the guy's got great weapons, he has that stately poise you'd expect from a king, and most important, he kicks ass! But since that's a list I probably could have come up with when I was fifteen, I'm guessing those aren't the real reasons the women I've talked to find Aragorn attractive.

So finally I asked them. I had to insert the question casually into conversation, between discussions of the weather and the war in Iraq, so as not to look too interested in the answer. Here's what they told me:

1. Aragorn is tough and manly, but doesn't swagger or act obnoxious.

2. His manhood isn't threatened by other males who are equally skilled warriors, or conversely, men who are, shall we say, less masculine than himself.

3. He's smart, level-headed, and balanced. He knows when it's time to play and when it's time to go to work.

4. He seems to have nothing to prove. He only wants to do what's right and to protect his people, and he seems to respect everyone, men and women, young and old, warrior and tradesperson.

5. He can charge into focused, full-on combat with his enemies, but when the battle is over, he comes back and takes up the mundane responsibilities of daily life without complaint.

6. He sings a mean coronation theme!

7. Most importantly, he knows how to treat a woman.

8. Furthermore, he respects the women in his life as equals, or at least as equally gifted and capable warrior-leaders.

In other words, Aragorn is everything a woman wants in a man, without all the things she doesn't want.

Now, a huge part of the credit for the Aragorn we see on the screen has to go to Viggo Mortensen. In real life, Mortensen is a poet, writer, musician, and photographer, and speaks four languages fluently - including Elvish. So that renaissance-man/sensitive-warrior quality can't help but play in his portrayal of Aragorn.

But that's irrelevant really. The point is, women love what they see. So is there something we men can learn from Aragorn? Not only when it comes to understanding what women are looking for, but simply what it means to be a man?

Ladies, what's the story?

________________________________________________________

For more on gender issues in The Lord of the Rings, visit

The Tolkien Online Forum

Does Gender Matter? Women, Tolkien, and the Online Fanfiction Community , Kristi Lee Brobeck

Macho Men & Warrior Princesses, Kara Gardner (@ Green Books)

A Shire of Her Own: Why This Lady Loves Lord of the Rings, Lynn Harris (@ The Simon)

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

Aragorn IS to die for... but Legolas isn't that far behind...

Anonymous said...

As I crawl out of some shady library on campus...straight from a 48 hour biochem study binge.... I snap back to reality, realizing that there is more to life than GSK-3 rxns (as interesting as glycogen synthesis is).... there is superficiality to be concerned with! And, let's face it we're only in school so we can get a job so that we will later be able to retire and concern ourselves with things that actually matter, like Viggo and his rugged good looks. I've asked around, done some research, and this is what I come up with...
Perhaps it was the camera angle he was shot at. If Aragorn was walking down the street, looking as he does... a few words might pop into mind... such as
Hobo..(not hobbit)...
transient ...
drifter...lowlife...
you might even cross the street to avoid conversation or, if he tried to talk to you, you might respond with some casual obscenities or violence... "Get away from me you #*#$"...you get my point.
But, when shot through some fancy-dancy camera...suddenly the "hobo/I don't shower look" becomes acceptable, even attractive. The basis for this theory was tested whilst aimlessly wandering down Whyte Ave.....and the results are in: Smell a hobo...no thanx... See a hobo...yes please.
So there you have it, The true reason that people are attracted to Aragorn is that everyone really likes the "hobo look" minus the ghastly smell. Maybe we just revert to some primitive instinct, we see hobo and think cave-man.
Hope I have enlightened you...

Anonymous said...

Not sure whether boys are allowed to play... Let me kick two more factors into the discussion:

1. He's faithful: even with Arwen far away and (as far as he knows) maybe even gone into The West, and the cute blonde Oewyn pretty much throwing herself at him, he stays with True Love.

2. And Viggo's cheekbones definitely can't be ruled out of the discussion!

I find that my teenage daughters fall for the slightly more girly Legolas (and let's not forget Olando's cheekbones either!), whereas more mature women seem to go for the more mature (and masculine) man.

But yeah, I think there's something about a deep masculine security that attracts women: as you said, Aragorn seems to have nothing to prove. He's happy to be in the background and just do what needs to be done, and to let (and help) others shine.

Anonymous said...

I'm trying to imagine how I would react if I saw Aragorn on Whyte Ave...

If it did enter my head (I can't say for certain it would) that he was a hobo I would frantically search my pockets for some change, lest in his anger from my lack of coin he should slay me with his giant sword. Heck, while we're at this game of time-warp, why not imagine Ryan Seacrest traversing Middle Earth alongside the Hobbits and everyone else.

At first I too wondered what all the fuss was about. I mean, to judge him from our standards Aragorn does seem a little on the hairy/dirty/bloodstained side. Paul, I think you summed up perfectly those qualities that make Aragorn so "scrumtrellescent". Qualities that transcend time and place.

I'd like to raise a question on qualities. It seems as though women look for sensitivity in men, yet the tough and rugged guys always hold this...appeal. What's the balance? Nobody wants a steroid pumping log lifter with the personality of a protein shake. And nobody wants a guy who weeps for days after seeing "Finding Nemo" for the third time. What's the right balance of GRUNT and GRACE?

Paul Donnett said...

Picco, your comment kicks ass! That deserves an article all by itself.
I've agonized over this one for years. For a long time I bought into the idea that women coveted sensitivity and openness as #1 attributes. That was until I started noticing the kinds of meatheads so many women seem to fall for. Honestly, I can't count the number of women I've talked to (especially is their 20s and 30s) who complain about how their boyfriends don't really seem to value their opinions, never open up about their own feelings, don't appreciate the finer things in life, etc.
When I ask, why then did you chose this guy, they sigh and tell me, "well he likes to hike", "he's a great dancer", "he has a good job", or that proven mainstay of any deep and enduring relationship, "he's hot".
What's the deal?? Do you want a guy who listens and cares or do you want the strong, silent type with five o'clock shadow?
I think I personally dig Aragorn because he seems to embody the best of both. I think in some ways, Aragorn's character answers the call (not his "hobo"-like appearance, c'mon people!) for a male role model that balances all the attributes that I think (what do I know?) women look for. Neither effiminate nor macho. Not emotionally closed off, but not a cry-baby either. A man who's able to take care of his woman without trying to run the show.
It's a topic that deserves special treatment. I feel an article coming. Thanks, Picco.

Paul Donnett said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Well Paul, you've done it again, piqued my interest in your thoughts.
On this particular matter I have to say, Aragorn, in all his ruggedly sexy handsomness (if that's a word)is exactly what you're saying, the perfect balance between strong and sensitive. But there's more to it than that, it's also his humility. He has no quams about stepping down and giving credit where it is due, and also knows when defence is necessary. There's nothing worse than a man who forever feels the need to one up everyone or always be on the defence. It's awesome to know that there are men out there that are proud of the women in their lives and their capabilities in this world. Also it's even nicer to see a man that doesn't need to be "macho" around his friends and prove himself as one of "the guys". I have to say, when I find a man like that... I'll make sure to try to be his soul mate.

Anonymous said...

Aragorn is THE man!
There is NO man on earth who is so attractive as he is!!!!!!!!!
So I was very pleased to read the text!
I am always falling off the couch when I'm seeing Lord of the Rings - he is really THE man - there is no one who can match him! And there weill never be! Viggo Mortensen looks sooo good!
He is wild, dark, sweaty, wet, wounded, strong, and all that, and ad you said, he doesn' play around in battle, he conzentrates and fights and....oh.... does it all so great! And his swinging cloak, his beard, his dark and dangerous expression... He is to die for!
Of course he is also very gentleman-like, and heroic of course, both really important. If I would want someone to rescue me (and I do!) I would take Aragorn without hesitation. And how he bows to Eowyn when he leaves.... I pity Eowyn so much!
And how he comes through the doors, wet and wounded in LotR 2....
Oh my, I could go on like this for EVER!
What I want to say is just:
ARAGORN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anonymous said...

something to be said for a man who can be a leader and not have to scream his head off and chew the scenery to prove his manliness, such as russell crowe, ewwwwww.