Tuesday, September 06, 2005

Katrina, Part 2: Rape, Racism, and Revolution


On August 31, I wrote about how wonderful and generous people can be when disaster strikes. Here is the flip side.

A few years ago, a friend was reflecting on the crisis in Rwanda and expressing his gratitude that we lived in an "advanced" society where such things - the lootings, rapes, murders, tribal conflicts - would never happen. He lamented about how education and "civilization" would have saved that country from catastrophe.

For a moment or two, I entertained the possibility. Most people, however, would quickly realize that his argument's central flaw was its naive assumption about how human nature works, that education and better laws make us better people fundamentally. While these might make us a more enlightened and better-regulated society, they barely make a dent when push comes to shove.

We human beings have been incurably hard-wired with two basic impulses: the need to survive and the desire to be happy. And we'll do just about anything, especially when threatened, to preserve these two things, no matter how civilized or educated we think we are. So we shouldn't be surprised (though we are justifiably dismayed) at some of the "Rwanda"-like behaviour we see down south, including murder, rape, looting, and shooting at relief workers trying to help you, for crying out loud! What's with that?? Turns out America, arguably the most "advanced" nation on earth, is just like everybody else: they just want to keep going, just want to be happy, and they'll do whatever it takes.

And can you blame them down in New Orleans? There's no excuse for the rapes and murders, but I have nothing but sympathy for some of the "looters" who are just looking for food, parents trying to get diapers, people looking for clothes. It's a little too smug to say we would never do the same, especially when they literally have nothing left. At that point, moral considerations take on a different colour. Dave asks at Bravus, "is property crime the big issue when dead bodies are lying in the streets, in the Louisiana heat, in the places where crowds of people are stranded, for days on end?" It's the whole question of what you do when faced with situations in which cherished values compete. Not as easy as it looks, is it?

Another friend sent me a link to two pictures, one in which a black man is "looting" but a white couple is merely "finding" food. I'm always slow to grab the race card (maybe because I'm white), but in Katrina's case, I'm tempted to agree. I mean, back in September '01, President Bush, the military, and relief agencies were in NY within hours. Granted, this is a very different kind of relief effort (caring for and relocating survivors vs. burying the dead) and on a significantly different scale (millions vs. a few thousand), but I don't think there's any question this could have been handled better.

Let's admit it: we rushed to New York's aid because it's the mostly white, white collar heart of the two things that matter most to America (or at least to it's leaders): power and money. Interestingly, these are just symbols of other, most basic needs: survival and happiness. Hmmm. In other words, America's leaders and the homeless survivors of Hurricane Katrina are really only after the same thing. You'd think this would create a bond of sympathy. So much for government "by and for the people". No constitution can change human nature.

Wake up, America, especially you guys in the expensive seats on Capitol Hill: your slip is showing. You've know for years that we're not all created equal. The difference is, post-9/11 and post-Katrina, we finally get it, too. Civilization, education, and money have not brought the classes together, they've only driven them farther apart. "Progress" has fractured America; if you don't believe it, just look southward. Fair enough, let's just stop pretending otherwise. But be careful: this is how revolutions get started.

No comments: